Skip to content

Kuespert Insurance Agency Blog

All You Ever Wanted to Know About Insurance

Why Certain Animals Can Increase Your Insurance Premiums?


Why Certain Animals Can Increase Your Insurance Premiums?

When it comes to protecting your home, auto, or business, insurance companies look at a variety of risk factors—including some that might surprise you. One often-overlooked detail that can affect your insurance premiums is animal ownership. At Panhandle Insurance, an independent insurance agency serving North Idaho, we’re here to help you understand why certain animals can impact your premiums—and how to navigate coverage to keep your finances secure.

1. Why Do Animals Affect Insurance Premiums?

Insurance is all about assessing risk. Certain animals—especially those considered dangerous or high-risk—increase the likelihood of liability claims or property damage. When insurers see increased risk, they may raise premiums or place restrictions on coverage.

2. Homeowners Insurance and Pets

A. Dog Breeds

Some dog breeds are considered higher risk by insurance carriers due to their size, strength, or historical bite statistics. Breeds commonly flagged include:

  • Pit Bulls
  • Rottweilers
  • Doberman Pinschers
  • German Shepherds
  • Wolf hybrids

While many owners of these breeds are responsible and their dogs are well-behaved, insurance companies often consider claims data showing higher rates of serious injuries or liability lawsuits involving these breeds.

Example: If a visitor is bitten by a dog on your property, homeowners insurance typically covers medical bills and legal fees. However, if your dog is a breed known for aggression—or if it has a history of biting—insurers may increase your liability premium or even exclude the dog from coverage.

B. Exotic Pets

Exotic animals, like snakes, monkeys, or large reptiles, present unique risks. They may:

  • Cause injury to guests or visitors
  • Escape and create a public safety hazard
  • Damage property inside or outside your home

Insurance companies often charge higher premiums or require special liability coverage for exotic pets.

3. Auto Insurance and Animals

A. Farm or Business Vehicles

If you transport livestock or other animals using your personal vehicle, insurers may classify your vehicle as commercial use, which typically costs more to insure.

B. Animal Collisions

Living in Idaho, you’re no stranger to wildlife on the roads. Deer collisions are common and can cause significant damage. While comprehensive auto insurance generally covers animal-related accidents, areas with high wildlife activity may have higher rates because of increased claims.

4. Farm and Ranch Insurance

In rural areas like North Idaho, many residents keep livestock, such as horses, cattle, or goats. These animals can pose risks:

  • Liability: A horse that escapes its enclosure and causes a traffic accident
  • Property damage: Animals damaging fencing, outbuildings, or neighboring properties
  • Medical expenses: Injuries to visitors or workers

Insurance carriers may charge higher premiums for farm or ranch properties that include certain animals, particularly those that have a history of causing injuries or are difficult to control.

5. What Can You Do to Manage These Costs?

A. Disclose All Animals

Always tell your insurance agent about the animals you own. Failure to disclose can result in denied claims or policy cancellation.

B. Implement Safety Measures

  • Install secure fencing
  • Keep up-to-date on vaccinations
  • Attend obedience training for dogs
  • Post warning signs where necessary

C. Work with an Independent Agent

At Panhandle Insurance, we’re not tied to a single carrier. We shop around to find insurers who offer reasonable rates, even for higher-risk animals, while ensuring you have the proper liability protection.

6. Why Choose Panhandle Insurance?

As an independent insurance agency serving North Idaho, we bring:

✅ Local Expertise: We understand the unique challenges of living in a region where animals—from farm livestock to beloved pets—are part of everyday life. 

✅ Customized Coverage: We work with multiple carriers to tailor a policy that fits your situation, including animal liability. 

✅ Advocacy: If you have a claim involving an animal, we’re on your side to make sure you get a fair resolution. 

✅ Honest Guidance: We’ll explain how animals can affect your premiums and help you make smart choices to protect your home, auto, or business.

7. The Bottom Line

Owning animals is a rewarding part of life in North Idaho, but it also comes with insurance considerations. Certain breeds, exotic pets, and livestock can increase your premiums due to higher risks of liability and property damage. At Panhandle Insurance, we’re here to help you navigate these complexities—ensuring you have the right coverage at the right price.

Ready to Talk Insurance? Contact Panhandle Insurance today for a free policy review or quote comparison. Let’s make sure your pets, livestock, and property are protected, so you can enjoy the Idaho lifestyle with peace of mind. 🐾🏠